Before Last Wish
The conversations worth having early

Family Conversations

Telling Siblings What You Have Been Asked To Do

An executor appointed quietly may be accused later of arranging things behind the family's back, which is why the appointment is worth disclosing while the parent is alive.

A mother and her two young boys enjoying breakfast together in a modern kitchen.
A mother and her two young boys enjoying breakfast together in a modern kitchen. · Photo via Pexels
Legal information notice. Educational information about planning — not legal advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Being named as executor is usually a private arrangement between a parent and one adult child. Keeping it private is where a large share of later family conflict begins.

Silence looks like something else afterwards

Siblings learning about the appointment after the death also learn that a conversation took place without them. The two facts arrive together and are read as one.

Even where the choice was entirely the parent's, the sibling who knew acquires the appearance of influence. Suspicion attaches to the secrecy rather than the outcome.

Disclosure while the parent is alive removes this, because the parent is present to confirm that it was their decision.

The role is work, not a reward

Families frequently interpret executorship as a mark of favour. It is closer to an unpaid administrative job carried out during a period of grief.

Explaining what it involves, such as valuations, tax filings, correspondence and distribution, tends to change how siblings see it fairly quickly.

It also opens the possibility that someone else would rather do it, or that two people should act together, which is far easier to arrange in advance.

What to disclose and what to withhold

Saying who has been appointed and where the will is kept is separate from disclosing its contents, which remains the parent's decision alone.

A useful line is that the appointment and the location of documents are shared, while the division of the estate is for the parent to discuss if they wish.

That distinction lets the executor be open about their role without becoming the person who tells siblings what they are getting.

Raising it without staging an event

A formal family meeting sets expectations of a revelation. Mentioning it in passing, during a visit or after an appointment, keeps the temperature low.

Where relations are already strained, a short written note to each sibling saying the same thing avoids the impression that different accounts were given to different people.

The parent's presence at that moment matters more than the wording. A sentence from them confirming that they chose, and why, is what the siblings will remember afterwards.

Keeping the record afterwards

Executors who send occasional short updates during administration face far fewer complaints, because delay looks like concealment when nobody is being told anything.

Duties, timescales and the extent of an executor's obligation to inform beneficiaries vary by jurisdiction and change. A solicitor can confirm what is required in a particular place.

organiserburdenfamily rolessupport
Margaret Oyelaran
Editor, Before Last Wish

Margaret spent nine years as a hospice social worker before turning to writing. She has sat through hundreds of these conversations and knows which ones people put off.

More from Margaret →

Also by Margaret Oyelaran

Family Conversations

The letter you leave behind

Of everything people leave, the thing most consistently valued is a letter, and it is the thing most consistently not written.

Margaret Oyelaran··4 min read

Family Conversations

When you are both the executor and the family

Administering an estate while grieving, for a family who are also beneficiaries, is a combination of roles that generates most of the complaints made against executors.

Daniel Krajewski··4 min read

Family Conversations

Telling people that someone has died

Delivering the news is exhausting, repetitive and frequently done badly for lack of any guidance on how.

Margaret Oyelaran··4 min read

Grief & After

Supporting someone who is grieving

People stay away because they do not know what to say. What is needed does not require the right words and does require turning up more than once.

Margaret Oyelaran··4 min read

Grief & After

Grief: what is normal and what to expect

Most of what people are told about grief is wrong, including the stages, the timeline and the idea that it is something to get over.

Margaret Oyelaran··4 min read

Grief & After

When you are the last one left

Outliving your generation is a particular kind of loss, rarely discussed, and it brings practical problems alongside the grief.

Margaret Oyelaran··4 min read